{ "schema_version": "var-dynamic-response-publication-boundary-v2.0", "generated_at": "2026-09-29", "role": "current publication-boundary registry; supplements (does not relabel) var_capability_status.json, which keeps its historical v1.88 schema", "estimator_available": true, "coefficient_estimation_available": true, "country_estimability": "five formal country/profile units estimable (unchanged)", "bic_lag_selection": "production_bic_unchanged", "historical_diagnostic_results": "retained_unchanged", "production_residual_diagnostic": "adjusted_portmanteau_h12_asymptotic", "production_residual_diagnostic_role": "historical observed diagnostic; not a validated finite-sample publication decision rule", "residual_publication_gate_status": "unresolved_no_validated_finite_sample_diagnostic", "validated_residual_publication_gate_available": false, "investigated_candidates": { "adjusted_portmanteau_asymptotic": "failed preregistered finite-sample joint calibration (v1.85); over-rejects ~21% with month dummies at the correct lag (v1.89)", "bg_lm": "not eligible (v1.85)", "edgerton_shukur_f": "not eligible (v1.85)", "selection_aware_recursive_iid_bootstrap": "passed an earlier synthetic gate (v1.86) but materially conservative with weak power in the country-matched region (v1.89); research only" }, "misspecification_interpretation": "historical asymptotic rejections are not conclusive evidence of misspecification: the asymptotic test is miscalibrated (v1.85/v1.89), the bootstrap did not reject (v1.88) but is conservative (v1.89), and attribution found weak diffuse dependence with no probe-removable misspecification (v1.90)", "formal_dynamic_response_publication_available": false, "formal_dynamic_response_ready_country_count": 0, "formal_irf_publication_available": false, "structural_identification_available": false, "irf_uncertainty_publication_available": false, "svar_available": false, "bvar_available": false, "production_changed": false, "bic_changed": false, "production_change_authorized": false, "new_capabilities_activated": false, "units": [ { "unit_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v1::poland", "country": "poland", "profile_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v1", "estimable": true, "production_selected_lag": 2, "existing_readiness_state": "residual_diagnostics_failed", "existing_blocking_reasons_zh": [ "主残差 Portmanteau 诊断 h=12 未通过；动态响应暂不可用" ], "stationarity_status": "stationary", "diagnostic_observed_result": { "diagnostic": "asymptotic adjusted Portmanteau h=12 (production)", "p_value": 0.021435024050539764, "observed_at_0_05": "rejects", "source": "var_country_lag_identifiability_results.json (v1.88, reproduces production readiness residual_status)", "existing_readiness_residual_status": "failed" }, "diagnostic_publication_gate_validity": "not_validated_finite_sample", "research_bootstrap_observation": { "p_value": 0.0715, "status": "research_only_not_eligible_as_gate (v1.89 conservative, weak power)" }, "residual_attribution_labels_v190": [ "cross_equation_lag_dependence", "break_outlier_concentrated" ], "conclusively_misspecified": false, "other_publication_blockers": [], "blockers_independent_of_residual_gate": false, "dynamic_response_publication_eligible": false, "reason_codes": [ "residual_publication_gate_unresolved" ] }, { "unit_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v1::romania", "country": "romania", "profile_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v1", "estimable": true, "production_selected_lag": 1, "existing_readiness_state": "estimable_with_warning", "existing_blocking_reasons_zh": [ "至少一个变量的 ADF 结果为 borderline；可估计但不开放动态响应" ], "stationarity_status": "borderline", "diagnostic_observed_result": { "diagnostic": "asymptotic adjusted Portmanteau h=12 (production)", "p_value": 0.2711237291735522, "observed_at_0_05": "does_not_reject", "source": "var_country_lag_identifiability_results.json (v1.88, reproduces production readiness residual_status)", "existing_readiness_residual_status": "passed" }, "diagnostic_publication_gate_validity": "not_validated_finite_sample", "research_bootstrap_observation": { "p_value": 0.296, "status": "research_only_not_eligible_as_gate (v1.89 conservative, weak power)" }, "residual_attribution_labels_v190": [ "little_residual_dependence", "cross_equation_lag_dependence", "break_outlier_concentrated" ], "conclusively_misspecified": false, "other_publication_blockers": [ "borderline_adf_stationarity" ], "blockers_independent_of_residual_gate": true, "dynamic_response_publication_eligible": false, "reason_codes": [ "residual_publication_gate_unresolved", "borderline_adf_stationarity" ] }, { "unit_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v2_seasonal_controls::czechia", "country": "czechia", "profile_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v2_seasonal_controls", "estimable": true, "production_selected_lag": 2, "existing_readiness_state": "estimable_with_warning", "existing_blocking_reasons_zh": [ "至少一个变量的 ADF 结果为 borderline；可估计但不开放动态响应" ], "stationarity_status": "borderline", "diagnostic_observed_result": { "diagnostic": "asymptotic adjusted Portmanteau h=12 (production)", "p_value": 0.03154374673832039, "observed_at_0_05": "rejects", "source": "var_country_lag_identifiability_results.json (v1.88, reproduces production readiness residual_status)", "existing_readiness_residual_status": "failed" }, "diagnostic_publication_gate_validity": "not_validated_finite_sample", "research_bootstrap_observation": { "p_value": 0.3535, "status": "research_only_not_eligible_as_gate (v1.89 conservative, weak power)" }, "residual_attribution_labels_v190": [ "seasonal_dynamic_dependence", "break_outlier_concentrated" ], "conclusively_misspecified": false, "other_publication_blockers": [ "borderline_adf_stationarity" ], "blockers_independent_of_residual_gate": true, "dynamic_response_publication_eligible": false, "reason_codes": [ "residual_publication_gate_unresolved", "borderline_adf_stationarity" ] }, { "unit_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v2_seasonal_controls::germany", "country": "germany", "profile_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v2_seasonal_controls", "estimable": true, "production_selected_lag": 2, "existing_readiness_state": "residual_diagnostics_failed", "existing_blocking_reasons_zh": [ "主残差 Portmanteau 诊断 h=12 未通过；动态响应暂不可用" ], "stationarity_status": "stationary", "diagnostic_observed_result": { "diagnostic": "asymptotic adjusted Portmanteau h=12 (production)", "p_value": 0.025594065606767358, "observed_at_0_05": "rejects", "source": "var_country_lag_identifiability_results.json (v1.88, reproduces production readiness residual_status)", "existing_readiness_residual_status": "failed" }, "diagnostic_publication_gate_validity": "not_validated_finite_sample", "research_bootstrap_observation": { "p_value": 0.2995, "status": "research_only_not_eligible_as_gate (v1.89 conservative, weak power)" }, "residual_attribution_labels_v190": [ "cross_equation_lag_dependence", "break_outlier_concentrated" ], "conclusively_misspecified": false, "other_publication_blockers": [], "blockers_independent_of_residual_gate": false, "dynamic_response_publication_eligible": false, "reason_codes": [ "residual_publication_gate_unresolved" ] }, { "unit_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v2_seasonal_controls::hungary", "country": "hungary", "profile_id": "baseline_monthly_macro_v2_seasonal_controls", "estimable": true, "production_selected_lag": 2, "existing_readiness_state": "estimable_with_warning", "existing_blocking_reasons_zh": [ "至少一个变量的 ADF 结果为 borderline；可估计但不开放动态响应" ], "stationarity_status": "borderline", "diagnostic_observed_result": { "diagnostic": "asymptotic adjusted Portmanteau h=12 (production)", "p_value": 0.04983323425256225, "observed_at_0_05": "rejects", "source": "var_country_lag_identifiability_results.json (v1.88, reproduces production readiness residual_status)", "existing_readiness_residual_status": "failed" }, "diagnostic_publication_gate_validity": "not_validated_finite_sample", "research_bootstrap_observation": { "p_value": 0.3905, "status": "research_only_not_eligible_as_gate (v1.89 conservative, weak power)" }, "residual_attribution_labels_v190": [ "cross_equation_lag_dependence", "break_outlier_concentrated" ], "conclusively_misspecified": false, "other_publication_blockers": [ "borderline_adf_stationarity" ], "blockers_independent_of_residual_gate": true, "dynamic_response_publication_eligible": false, "reason_codes": [ "residual_publication_gate_unresolved", "borderline_adf_stationarity" ] } ], "program_status": { "state": "frozen_after_v2_0", "reopening_requires": [ "genuinely new methodological evidence or a separately preregistered research question", "owner approval" ], "registered_future_directions_not_authorized": [ "pandemic-period variance/outlier handling", "HICP seasonal dynamics" ] }, "references": { "var_capability_status.json": "2a7f762a7535ef13040fb0ece34218587a9341432a1cf673425dfb66bc2375d0", "var_country_readiness.json": "4b8173f8202c72359758b0bf4b05ef08a6c089f2ab47f79b7be359468c97e6b1", "var_baseline_v1_readiness.json": "f210b02ec3042c5cf95f975bccbd94f7fead0f403314d59a1e760a2046c5912e", "var_baseline_v2_readiness.json": "b7fd4bec330ebd4db588ed63bce4de988773556b8cdc572c27f640239a2a1675", "var_country_lag_identifiability_results.json": "b7d876ca7d2ada83a493d6390dcb685c11516b0a8a2268045e29e5b85adf7d70", "var_phase_b_bootstrap_results.json": "489f85dc0be9d90539c88a6bbc5ffa5432b5ac575e0df88ddbea657ab10187a8", "var_country_matched_bootstrap_research_conclusion.json": "12b93d3d5144f2aa1ca3cd44713ce591870335051d9d88eb48196744bb15c1a7", "var_residual_attribution_research_conclusion.json": "8ada3eb4c4c796af91cb529300772f778bcb57ce68573083d8dfb9f586b8ba5b" } }